The Best Order to Unlock the Eggs Efficiently
I’ve seen a lot of people bouncing all over the place trying to finish the Egg Hunt in MLB The Show 25, so I wanted to share the order I followed tmlb 25 stubso get all the eggs in the least amount of time. This isn’t the only way, but it saved me a lot of grinding.
Start with the Moments – Knock these out first. You’ll get an egg and a player card or two to help with other missions.
Conquest Map Next – While completing the Egg Hunt map, you can also collect Jelly Beans and win games that count for the triple or jelly bean egg.
Jump into Showdown – Just take out the first two bosses. Build your team around contact hitters and you’ll be done in 15 minutes.
Mini Seasons – Play on All-Star against an easier team. Focus on speed and triples while you're in here.
Events Mode – Hit your doubles. If you also hit a triple here, great—you’re checking two off at once.
Battle Royale – Draft Wade Boggs and try to get on base. Might take a few drafts, so patience helps.
Ranked Seasons – Go for a steal with a speedy guy. Lofton, Bichette, or a Road to the Show speedster works wonders.
Play a Full 9-Inning Game vs CPU – Do this last when you want a chill session. Put it on Rookie and swing away.
I wrapped up the whole hunt over a weekend. You can do most of these eggs in under an hour each if you're focused. And the best part is a lot of them overlap—like collecting jelly beans during Conquest or Showdown.
Hope this helps someone save time. It’s a great event but a lot smoother when you go in with a plan.